Binding of yeast and human cytochrome c to cardiolipin nanodiscs at physiological ionic strength

Binding of cytochrome c (Cytc) to membranes containing cardiolipin (CL) is of considerable interest because of the importance of this interaction in the early stages of apoptosis. The molecular-level determinants of this interaction are still not well defined and there appear to be species-specific differences in Cytc affinity for CL-containing membranes. Many studies are carried out at low ionic strength far from the 100-150 mM ionic strength within mitochondria. Similarly, most binding studies are done at Cytc concentrations of 10 μM or less, much lower that the estimated range of 0.1 to 5 mM Cytc present in mitochondria. In this study, we evaluate binding of human and yeast Cytc to CL nanodiscs using size exclusion chromatography at 25 μM Cytc concentration and 100 mM ionic strength. We find that yeast Cytc affinity for CL nanodiscs is much stronger than that of human Cytc. Mutational analysis of the site A binding surface shows that lysines 86 and 87 are more important for yeast Cytc binding to CL nanodiscs than lysines 72 and 73, counter to results at lower ionic strength. Analysis of the electrostatic surface potential of human versus yeast Cytc shows that the positive potential due to lysines 86 and 87 and other nearby lysines (4, 5, 11, 89) is stronger than that due to lysines 72 and 73. In the case of human Cytc the positive potential around site A is less uniform and likely weakens electrostatic binding to CL membranes through site A.