Mating Assay: Plating Below a Cell Density Threshold is Required for Unbiased Estimation of Plasmid Conjugation...

Mating assays are common laboratory experiments for measuring the conjugation frequency, i.e. efficiency at which a plasmid transfers from a population of donor cells to a population of recipient cells. Selective plating remains a widely used quantification method to enumerate transconjugants at the end of such assays. However, conjugation frequencies may be inaccurately estimated because plasmid transfer can occur on transconjugant-selective plates rather than only during the intended mating duration. We investigated the influence of cell density on this phenomenon. We conducted mating experiments with IncPα plasmid RP4 harbored in Escherichia coli at a fixed cell density and mating conditions, inoculated a serial dilution of the mating mixture on transconjugant-selective plates or in transconjugant-selective broth, and compared the results to a model of cell-to-cell distance distribution. Our findings suggest that irrespective of the mating mode (liquid vs solid), the enumeration of transconjugants becomes significantly biased if the plated cell density exceeds 28 Colony Forming Unit (CFU)/mm² (or 1.68•10⁵ CFU/standard 9 cm Petri dish). This threshold is determined with a 95% confidence interval of ± 4 CFU/mm² (± 2.46•10⁴ CFU/standard 9 cm Petri dish). Liquid mating assays were more sensitive to this bias because the conjugation frequency of RP4 is several orders of magnitude lower in suspension compared to surface mating. Therefore, if selective plating is used, we recommend to plate at this density threshold and that negative controls are performed where donors and recipients are briefly mixed before plating at the same dilutions as for the actual mating assay. As an alternative, a liquid enumeration method can be utilized to increase the signal-to-noise ratio and allow for more accurate enumeration of transconjugants.