Prediction of prognosis in supramalleolar osteotomy with or without additional fibula osteotomy by approaching a...

Supramalleolar osteotomy (SMO) is a representative procedure to restore a malalignment in the varus ankle deformity by shifting the concentrated pressure on the medial ankle joint to the lateral area. Additionally, fibula osteotomy (FO) is selectively selected and performed according to the surgeon's preference. However, it is controversial whether FO is effective in shifting the abnormal pressure from the medial to the lateral area on the ankle joint. Some cadaveric studies have been performed to prove this. However, it is difficult to consistently reconstruct amount of the varus ankle deformities angle in cadavers and to guarantee reliable contact pressure between the ankle joint. Thus, the aim of this study was predicted and quantitatively compared a peak pressure between single SMO and SMO with FO procedure by using a finite element analysis as a powerful biomechanical tool to those limitations of cadaveric study. This study reconstructed total 4 3D foot and ankle models including a normal and pre-op model and 2 post-op models. The pre-op model was modified by assigning 10° varus tilting corresponding to stage 3b in the classification of varus ankle osteoarthritis based on the validated normal model. Also, the post-op models were reconstructed by applying single SMO and SMO with FO, respectively. All of the models were assumed as one-leg standing position and to mimic smooth ankle joint motion. Peak contact pressure change was predicted at the medial ankle joint by using computational simulation. As a result, 2 post-op models showed a remarkably peak pressure reduction by up to 5.5 times on the medial tibiotalar joint. However, a comparison between single SMO and SMO with FO model showed no appreciable differences. In conclusion, this study predicted that single SMO may be as effective as SMO with FO in reducing peak contact pressure on the medial tibiotalar joint in varus ankle osteoarthritis.