Spider silk tensile performance does not correlate with web use

Spider silk is amongst the toughest materials produced by living systems, but its tensile performance varies considerably between species. Despite the extensive sampling of the material properties and composition of dragline silk, the understanding of why some silks performs better than others is still limited. Here, I adopted a phylogenetic comparative approach to reanalyze structural and mechanical data from the Silkome database and the literature across 164 species to (a) provide an extended model of silk property evolution, (b) test for correlations between structural and mechanical properties, and (c) to test if silk tensile performance differs between web-building and nonweb-building species. Unlike the common notion that orb-weavers have evolved the best-performing silks, outstanding tensile properties were found both in and outside the araneoid clade. Phylogenetic linear models indicated that the mechanical and structural properties of spider draglines poorly correlate, but silk strength and toughness correlated better with birefringence (an indicator of the material anisotropy) than crystallinity. Furthermore, in contrast to previous ideas, silk tensile performance did not differ between ecological guilds. These findings indicate multiple unknown pathways toward the evolution of spider silk tensile super-performance, calling for better integration of nonorb-weaving spiders in spider silk studies.