Matched pair analysis of the effect of longer hypothermic machine perfusion time on kidney transplant outcomes

Hypothermic machine perfusion (HMP) has demonstrated benefits in terms of early kidney transplant function compared to static cold storage. While longer preservation times have shown detrimental effects, a previous paired study indicated that longer pump times (the second kidney in a pair) might lead to improved outcomes.

To revisit the prior paired study's somewhat unexpected results by reviewing our program's experience.

A total of 61 pairs of transplant recipients who received kidneys from the same donor (2012-2021) were analyzed. Patients were divided into two groups depending on whether they were transplanted first (K1) or second (K2). Therefore, the patients in each pair had identical donor characteristics, except for time on the pump. Statistical analyses included Kaplan-Meyer analysis and paired tests, including McNemar's test, student's paired t-test, or Wilcoxon's test, as appropriate.

The two groups of recipients had similar demographics (age, body mass index, diabetes, time on dialysis, sensitization and retransplants). Cold ischemic times for K1 and K2 were 8.9 (95%CI: 7.9, 9.8) and 14.7 hours (13.7, 15.8) (P < 0.0001), respectively. Overall, K2 had a higher rate of freedom from biopsy-proven acute rejection at 1 year (P = 0.015). Delayed graft function was less common in K2, 12/61 (20%) than in K1, 20/61 (33%) (P = 0.046). Finally, K2 showed a higher graft survival than K1 (P = 0.023).

Our results agree with a previous study that suggested possible advantages to longer pump times. Both studies should encourage further research into HMP's potential anti-inflammatory effect.