Mobile phone conversation during nighttime driving: Effects on driving behavior

This study aims to investigate the impact of mobile phone use (specifically, conversation), considering various use modes, on driving behavior at night. Mobile phone use is a source of driver distraction and has been associated with increased accident risk. Driving at night also entails higher accident risk and severity compared to daytime driving. Several studies have investigated the impact of mobile phone use on driving behavior; however, only a few have explored the differences between the different use modes. Most present studies involved daytime driving, although mobile phone use at night is equally if not more prevalent.

A driving simulator experiment was designed in which 55 participants drove under nighttime simulator conditions, in different road environments (urban and rural) and under different types of distraction: no distraction, handheld, wired earphone, and speaker mode. The drives were performed during late afternoon and evening hours to resemble nighttime conditions both in the simulator and in the actual environment. Participants also completed a questionnaire for collection of different types of data.

Results highlight the effect of mobile phone use on driving behavior, through specific indicators. Mobile phone use resulted in reduced 85th percentile driving speed and 85th percentile acceleration and increased reaction time and lateral deviation. However, safer stopping distance was observed in rural roads. Parameters relative to mobile phone use familiarity and exposure were found to mitigate mobile phone use effects.

Mobile phones affect driving behavior at night in a similar manner to that noted in several different studies considering daytime driving. The hands-free regulation should be revisited, because driver distraction also occurred under this particular use mode. Further research is required considering mobile phone use familiarity and exposure and effects of mobile phone use, because the latter is reduced with an increase in the former. Stopping distance, an understudied but more immediate surrogate measure of road safety, was increased with mobile phone use, mainly as a result of the risk compensation behavior that drivers adopt, indicating that more research is required in this field.