Freshwater Habitats Promote Rapid Rates of Phenotypic Evolution in Sculpin Fishes (Perciformes: Cottoidea)

AbstractInvasions of freshwater habitats by marine fishes provide exceptional cases of habitat-driven biological diversification. Freshwater habitats make up less than 1% of aquatic habitats but contain ∼50% of fish species. However, while the dominant group of freshwater fishes (Otophysi) is older than that of most marine fishes (Percomorphaceae), it is less morphologically diverse. Classically, scientists have invoked differences in the tempo and/or mode of evolution to explain such cases of unequal morphological diversification. We tested for evidence of these phenomena in the superfamily Cottoidea (sculpins), which contains substantial radiations of marine and freshwater fishes. We find that the morphology of freshwater sculpins evolves faster but under higher constraint than that of marine sculpins, causing widespread convergence in freshwater sculpins and more morphological disparity in marine sculpins. The endemic freshwater sculpins of Lake Baikal, Siberia, are exceptions that demonstrate elevated novelty akin to that of marine sculpins. Several tantalizing factors may explain these findings, such as differences in habitat stability and/or habitat connectivity between marine and freshwater systems.