A Method for Treating Significant Conformational Changes in Alchemical Free Energy Simulations of Protein-Ligand...

Relative binding free energy (RBFE) simulation is a rigorous approach to the calculation of quantitatively accurate binding free energy values for protein-ligand binding in which a reference binder is gradually converted to a target binder through alchemical transformation during the simulation. The success of such simulations relies on being able to accurately sample the correct conformational phase space for each alchemical state; however, this becomes a challenge when a significant conformation change occurs between the reference and target binder-receptor complexes. Increasing the simulation time and using enhanced sampling methods can be helpful, but effects can be limited, especially when the free energy barrier between conformations is high or when the correct target complex conformation is difficult to find and maintain. Current RBFE protocols seed the reference complex structure into every alchemical window of the simulation. In our study, we describe an improved protocol in which the reference structure is seeded into the first half of the alchemical windows, and the target structure is seeded into the second half of the alchemical windows. By applying information about the relevant correct end point conformations to different simulation windows from the beginning, the need for large barrier crossings or simulation prediction of the correct structures during an alchemical simulation is in many cases obviated. In the diverse cases we examine below, the simulations yielded free energy predictions that are satisfactory as compared to experiment and superior to running the simulations utilizing the conventional protocol. The method is straightforward to implement for publicly available FEP workflows.