Mass Spectral Feature Analysis of Ubiquitylated Peptides Provides Insights into Probing the Dark Ubiquitylome

Ubiquitylation is a structurally and functionally diverse post-translational modification that involves the covalent attachment of the small protein ubiquitin to other protein substrates. Trypsin-based proteomics is the most common approach for globally identifying ubiquitylation sites. However, we estimate that such methods are unable to detect ∼40% of ubiquitylation sites in the human proteome, i.e., "the dark ubiquitylome", including many important for human health and disease. In this meta-analysis of three large ubiquitylomic data sets, we performed a series of bioinformatic analyses to assess experimental features that could aid in uniquely identifying site-specific ubiquitylation events. Spectral predictions from Prosit were compared to experimental spectra of tryptic ubiquitylated peptides, revealing previously uncharacterized fragmentation of the diGly scar. Analysis of the LysC-derived ubiquitylated peptides reveals systematic, multidimensional peptide fragmentation, including diagnostic b-ions from fragmentation of the LysC ubiquitin scar. Comprehensively, these findings provide diagnostic spectral signatures of modification events that could be applied to new analysis methods for nontryptic ubiquitylomics.