Interrogating post-transplant donor HLA-specific antibody characteristics and effector functions using clinical bead...

Single antigen bead (SAB) assays are the most common and sensitive method used to detect and monitor post-transplant donor specific HLA antibodies (DSA). However, a direct comparison across traditional and modified SAB assays to improve routine DSA monitoring using pre-treated IgG sera to eliminate interference has not been performed. We performed a technical comparison of 251 post-transplant DSA from n = 91 serum samples tested neat (pre-treated, undiluted), at a single 1:16 dilution, in the C1q bead assay, and for IgG subclasses (IgG1, IgG2, IgG3, IgG4) with IgG-enriched sera. We found that DSAs that are detectable by 1:16 dilution and/or C1q are associated with higher IgG MFI values and results could be predicted by testing neat sera. DSA detected at 1:16 dilution correlated with >7000 IgG MFI in neat sera and identified DSA that exceeded the SAB linear range for semiquantitative measurements. C1q positive DSA correlated with >15,000 IgG MFI in neat sera. C1q binding correlated most strongly with total IgG MFI (Spearman r = 0.82, p = 0.002) and not specific subclasses, demonstrating that DSA C1q binding capacity in this cohort is driven by HLA-specific IgG concentration. Evaluation of engineered pan-HLA class I-specific human IgG1 and IgG2 subclass monoclonal antibodies by SAB C1q and C3d assays revealed that IgG2 antibodies can bind complement at higher concentrations. The strengths and limitations of modified SAB assays must be considered to optimize efficient testing and accurate clinical interpretation.