Effect of Ultrahigh Dose Rate on Biomolecular Radiation Damage

Dose rate is one of the important parameters in radiation-induced biomolecular damage. The effects of dose rate have been known to modify radiation toxicity in biological systems. The rate and extent of sublethal DNA damage (e.g., base damage and single-strand breaks) repair and those of cell proliferation have been manifested by dose rate. However, the recent preclinical application of ultrahigh dose rate [(UHDR) ca. 40 Gy/s and higher] radiation modalities have been shown to lower the type and extent of radiation damage to biological systems. At these UHDR, radiation-induced physicochemical and chemical processes are expected to differ from those observed after irradiation at conventional dose rates (CONV). It is unclear whether these UHDR conditions can affect the quality (type) and quantity (extent) of biomolecular damage such as DNA lesions. Here, we comparatively study the influence of indirect effects of CONV and UHDR on the formation of DNA strand breaks and clustered damage including densely accumulated lesions in an aerated and an anoxic dilute aqueous solution of a plasmid DNA model under low and high hydroxyl radical (•OH) scavenging conditions. Aqueous solutions of purified supercoiled plasmid DNA (pUC19) were prepared in either air- or nitrogen-saturated conditions, with Tris buffer added as the radiation-produced •OH scavenger at low and high scavenging capacities. These DNA samples were irradiated using kV X-ray systems at CONV (0.1 Gy/s) and high dose rate (HDR, 25 Gy/s) as well as UHDR (55 and 125 Gy/s) under different scavenging and environmental conditions. DNA lesions including strand breaks and clustered damage including densely accumulated lesions were quantified by gel electrophoresis and the yields of these lesions were calculated from the dose-response curve. Non-DSB clustered damage including densely accumulated lesions were evaluated by treating DNAs using bacterial endonuclease enzymes (Fpg and Nth) prior to gel electrophoresis. UHDR of 55 and 125 Gy/s induced lower amounts of both isolated strand breaks and clustered DNA damage including densely accumulated lesions at doses >40 Gy in the presence of oxygen, compared to the abundance of these lesions induced by 0.1 and 25 Gy/s irradiation under the same dose conditions. Overall, the strand break and clustered damage including densely accumulated lesions yields decreased by factors of 1.3-3.5 after UHDR. We did not observe these differences either via •OH scavenging or by removing oxygen from the solution. In addition, our results point out that the inter-track recombination reactions did not contribute to the observed dose-rate effects on DNA damage. The effects of dose rate on DNA damage are highly dependent on the total dose, as expected, but also on the •OH scavenging capacity that is employed in the aqueous DNA solutions. These important variables may be relevant in biological systems as well. On a practical level, our in vitro plasmid DNA model, which permits to precisely vary the •OH scavenging capacity and gassing conditions (air saturated vs. N2 saturated) can help to differentiate dose-rate effects on biomolecular damage. Our results indicate that the radical-radical reactions are important in understanding the dose-rate effect on DNA damage.