Seeds of language-like generativity in bird call combinations

Language is unbounded in its generativity, enabling the flexible combination of words into novel sentences. Critically, these constructions are intelligible to others due to our ability to derive a sentence's compositional meaning from the semantic relationships among its components. Some animals also concatenate meaningful calls into compositional-like combinations to communicate more complex information. However, these combinations are structurally highly stereotyped, suggesting a bounded system of holistically perceived signals that impedes the processing of novel variants. Using long-term data and playback experiments on pied babblers, we demonstrate that, despite production stereotypy, they can nevertheless process structurally modified and novel combinations of their calls, demonstrating a capacity for deriving meaning compositionally. Furthermore, differential responses to artificial combinations by fledglings suggest that this compositional sensitivity is acquired ontogenetically. Our findings demonstrate animal combinatorial systems can be flexible at the perceptual level and that such perceptual flexibility may represent a precursor of language-like generativity.