Evolution in microbial microcosms is highly parallel, regardless of the presence of interacting species

Evolution often follows similar trajectories in replicate populations, suggesting that it may be predictable. However, populations are naturally embedded in multispecies communities, and the extent to which evolution is contingent on the specific species interacting with the focal population is still largely unexplored. Here, we study adaptations in strains of 11 different species, experimentally evolved both in isolation and in various pairwise co-cultures. Although partner-specific effects are detectable, evolution was mostly shared between strains evolved with different partners; similar changes occurred in strains' growth abilities, in community properties, and in about half of the repeatedly mutated genes. This pattern persisted even in species pre-adapted to the abiotic conditions. These findings indicate that evolution may not always depend strongly on the biotic environment, making predictions regarding coevolutionary dynamics less challenging than previously thought. A record of this paper's transparent peer review process is included in the supplemental information.