Surgical treatment of hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer

From 1980 to 1984, 48 patients were subjected to liver resection for hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer. The disease was staged according to the original staging system proposed by the authors: stage I, single metastasis involving less than 25% of hepatic parenchyma (21 patients); stage II, multiple metastases involving less than 25% of hepatic parenchyma or single metastasis involving between 25-50% (9 patients); and stage III, multiple metastases involving between 25-50% or more than 50% of hepatic parenchyma, irrespective of the number of metastases (18 patients). The extent of hepatic resection was generally related to that of liver disease; a typical lobectomy was performed in 28 patients and segmentectomies in 20. One patient died after operation (mortality, 2.1%), and major complications occurred in seven patients (morbidity, 14.9%). Morbidity was related to operatory blood loss: 45% of patients with blood replacement of more than 2000 cc developed major complications versus 5.4% with blood replacement of less than 2000 cc (p less than 0.05). The actuarial 3-year survival for stages I, II, and III was 73%, 60%, and 29%, respectively (p less than 0.05). Twenty-two patients (45%) have had recurrences, all stage III patients within 2 years of resection versus 28% of stage I patients (30 months disease-free survival, 49%). The liver only was the site of recurrence in 10 patients, distant sites in seven, and both liver and distant in five. Analysis of the different features of the primary tumor, the interval between bowel resection and detection of hepatic metastases, and the number and extent of liver secondaries demonstrated that prognosis after surgery was mainly related to the latter; they are considered in the staging system adopted in this study. It is a simple system and shows a good prognostic correlation. The results reported here are in agreement with those of the literature; the low mortality and morbidity and the survival benefit support the growing acceptance of surgery in treatment of hepatic metastases from colorectal cancer, in particular stage I patients. For the other stages, surgery should represent, when applicable, only the first step of a multimodality treatment.