The feasibility of surgical enucleation for renal cell carcinoma

Although partial nephrectomy for renal cell carcinoma has been recommended for tumors in solitary kidneys, surgical enucleation has been suggested as an alternative form of surgical management in highly selected patients. To verify the efficacy of surgical enucleation the surgical specimens from 16 standard radical nephrectomies were dissected carefully. The tumors were enucleated ex vivo and carefully investigated pathologically. It was possible to enucleate successfully some well circumscribed, low grade tumors but venous invasion, tumor heterogeneity, occult metastatic disease in lymph nodes, satellite tumor nodules in the kidney and extrinsic spread through the renal capsule were features that may not have been appreciated fully in the operating room. Computerized tomography could not always predict which patients were possible enucleation candidates. Partial nephrectomy remains the preferred surgical treatment in a parenchymal-sparing operation rather than simple enucleation.