The Knowns and Unknowns of Membrane Features and Changes During Autophagosome-Lysosome/Vacuole Fusion

Autophagosome (AP)-lysosome/vacuole fusion is one of the hallmarks of macroautophagy. Membrane features and changes during the fusion process have mostly been described using two-dimensional (2D) models with one AP and one lysosome/vacuole. The outer membrane (OM) of a closed mature AP has been suggested to fuse with the lysosomal/vacuolar membrane. However, the descriptions in some studies for fusion-related issues are questionable or incomplete. The correct membrane features of APs and lysosomes/vacuoles are the prerequisite for describing the fusion process. We searched the literature for representative membrane features of AP-related structures based on electron microscopy (EM) graphs of both animal and yeast cells and re-evaluated the findings. We also summarized the main 2D models describing the membrane changes during AP-lysosome/vacuole fusion in the literature. We used three-dimensional (3D) models to characterize the known and unknown membrane changes during and after fusion of the most plausible 2D models. The actual situation is more complex, since multiple lysosomes may fuse with the same AP in mammalian cells, multiple APs may fuse with the same vacuole in yeast cells, and in some mutant cells, phagophores (unclosed APs) fuse with lysosomes/vacuoles. This review discusses the membrane features and highly dynamic changes during AP (phagophore)-lysosome/vacuole fusion. The resulting information will improve the understanding of AP-lysosome/vacuole fusion and direct the future research on AP-lysosome/vacuole fusion and regeneration.