Genetic heterogeneity in adenosine deaminase (ADA) deficiency: five different mutations in five new patients with...

Complete genetic deficiency of adenosine deaminase (ADA) results in a fatal syndrome of severe combined immunodeficiency (SCID). Genetic partial deficiency of ADA, with no detectable enzyme activity in erythrocytes but with variable amounts of enzyme activity detectable in other cells, is usually associated with normal immunologic function but can give rise to a late-onset, cellular immunodeficiency syndrome. We have previously described four different mutant alleles in four such partially ADA-deficient children. We have now examined ADA in lymphoid cells from five additional newly ascertained children with partial ADA deficiency with respect to electrophoretic mobility in starch gel, isoelectric point, heat-stability, and apparent Km and Vmax. These techniques identify at least five different abnormal alleles in these five additional unrelated subjects. Three of these abnormal alleles result in expression of abnormal allelic isozymes (allozymes) different from those previously described. These are: (1) an acidic allozyme that is less acidic than the acidic allozyme we have previously reported; (2) an allozyme that is even less acidic than (1); and (3) an allozyme with apparently normal charge but which is so heat sensitive that the lability to heat can easily be detected at physiologic to febrile temperatures. Two abnormal alleles detected in these five children could correspond with previously reported mutants. These are (4) a basic allozyme that could (but probably doesn't) correspond to the basic allozyme we have previously reported and (5) a "null" allele that cannot be differentiated by these methods from any other "null" allele seen in complete ADA- -SCIDs. Three of the five new patients are genetic compounds, identified either by the presence of two electrophoretically distinguishable allozymes or by family studies that demonstrate presence of a "null" allele in addition to an electrophoretically abnormal allozyme. In three patients, one or both allozymes are phenotypically indistinguishable from an abnormal allozyme also seen in a different individual. Determination of the nucleotide sequence will be required to determine whether or not the phenotypically indistinguishable mutations are indeed genotypically identical. The newly ascertained individuals appear to share a common ethnic West Indian background, out of proportion to the frequency of this ethnic background in the newborn population from which they were ascertained, suggesting that partial ADA deficiency may confer a selective advantage to the homozygous or heterozygous phenotype.