Validation of QTLs associated with corn borer resistance and grain yield: implications in maize breeding

Validations of previously detected quantitative trait loci (QTLs) to assess their reliability are crucial before implementing breeding programs. The objective of this study was to determine the reliability and practical usefulness of previously reported QTLs for resistance to stem tunneling by the Mediterranean stem borer (MSB) and yield. These authors used approximately 600 recombinant inbred lines (RILs) from a multiparent advanced generation intercross (MAGIC) population to map QTL using a genome-wide association study (GWAS) approach.

We identified RILs situated at the extremes of resistance and yield distributions within the whole MAGIC, and those QTLs were evaluated per se and crossed to a tester (A638) using lattice designs. In each set, a significant single-nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) was considered validated if (1) the same SNP was associated with the trait with a p-value < 0.02, or (2) within a ±2-Mbp interval, an SNP associated with the trait exhibited a p-value < 0.02 and demonstrated linkage disequilibrium (r2 > 0.2) with the SNPs previously reported.

The novel QTL validation approach was implemented using improved experimental designs that led to higher heritability estimates for both traits compared to those estimated with the whole MAGIC population. The procedure used allowed us to jointly validate several QTL and to ascertain their possible contribution to hybrid improvement. Specifically, nearly three-quarters of the QTLs for tunnel length were confirmed. Notably, QTLs located in the genomic region 6.05-6.07 were consistently validated across different sets and have been previously linked to resistance against stalk tunneling in various mapping populations. For grain yield, approximately 10 out of 16 QTLs were validated. The validation rate for yield was lower than for tunnel length, likely due to the influence of dominance and/or epistatic effects. Overall, 9 out of 21 QTLs for tunnel length and 6 out of 17 QTLs for grain yield identified in our previous research were validated across both validation sets, indicating a moderate genetic correlation between per se and testcross performance of inbred lines. These findings offer insights into the reliability of QTL and genomic predictions, both derived from assessments conducted on the entire MAGIC population. Genomic predictions for tunnel length based on inbred line evaluations could be useful to develop more resistant hybrids; meanwhile, genomic prediction for yield could only be valid in a homozygous background.