Sequence variation in the active site of mobile colistin resistance proteins is evolutionarily accommodated through...

Sequence variation among homologous proteins can shed light on their function and ancestry. In this study, we analyze variation at catalytic residues among MCR (mobile colistin resistance) proteins, which confer resistance to the last resort antibiotic, colistin, in gram-negative bacteria. We show that not all naturally occurring variants at a lipid A-binding residue, Ser284, are tolerated in MCR-1. In particular, the substitution of Ser284 with Asp, found naturally in MCR-5, resulted in diminished colistin resistance. Using phylogenetic analyses and structure predictions we trace back variation at this site among MCRs to their ancestors, i.e. EptA phosphoethanolamine transferases that are encoded by diverse bacterial genomes. Mutational studies and AlphaFold-based structural modeling revealed that the functional importance of position 284 varies between phylogenetically distant MCRs, i.e. MCR-1 and MCR-5. Despite a high degree of similarity among their catalytic domains, inter-domain interactions were not conserved between MCR-1 and MCR-5 due to their different ancestries, providing a mechanistic basis behind the different phenotypes of similar mutations at position 284. Our study thus uncovers subtle differences in the organization of domains among MCR proteins that can lead to substantial differences in their catalytic properties and mutational tolerances.