Temporal patterns and individual characteristics of compulsory treatment orders for mental disorders in Scotland from...

Compulsory mental health treatment has increased globally. In Scotland, compulsory treatment for >28 days is permitted under hospital- and community-based compulsory treatment orders. Community-based compulsory treatment has not been shown to lead to improved outcomes, and scrutiny of their use is needed.

To describe the trend, duration and demographic characteristics of compulsory treatment orders in Scotland over a 14-year period.

We conducted a retrospective analysis of order use in Scotland from 1 January 2007 to 31 December 2020, focusing on the (a) number and demographic characteristics of those treated, (b) duration, (c) extensions beyond the 6-month review point and (d) characteristics of new versus continued orders.

The number of individuals on a community-based order increased by 118% (571 v. 1243) from 2007 to 2020, compared with a 16% increase (1316 v. 1532) for hospital-based orders. Of orders starting in 2007, 57.3% were extended, compared with 43.7% in 2020. The median duration was 6 months for first-time orders and 9 months for subsequent orders, which were longest for males (median 11 months); those of African, Caribbean or Black (median 11 months), Asian (median 11 months) and mixed ethnicity (median 10 months); and individuals from the most deprived communities (median 10 months).

There has been a marked rise of community-based compulsory treatment orders in Scotland. If existing trends continue, there will be more people receiving care under community-based orders than hospital-based orders, fundamentally changing the nature of involuntary treatment. Further work needs to explore associations between demographic and diagnostic characteristics on order duration.