Unintended Consequences of Data Sharing Under the Meaningful Use Program

Interoperability has been designed to improve the quality and efficiency of health care. It allows the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services to collect data on quality measures as a part of the Meaningful Use program. Covered providers who fail to provide data have lower rates of reimbursement. Unintended consequences also arise at each step of the data collection process: (1) providers are not reimbursed for the extra time required to generate data; (2) patients do not have control over when and how their data are provided to or used by the government; and (3) large datasets increase the chances of an accidental data breach or intentional hacker attack. After detailing the issues, we describe several solutions, including an appropriate data use review board, which is designed to oversee certain aspects of the process and ensure accountability and transparency.