A Two-Step Q-Matrix Estimation Method

Cognitive Diagnosis Models in educational measurement are restricted latent class models that describe ability in a knowledge domain as a composite of latent skills an examinee may have mastered or failed. Different combinations of skills define distinct latent proficiency classes to which examinees are assigned based on test performance. Items of cognitively diagnostic assessments are characterized by skill profiles specifying which skills are required for a correct item response. The item-skill profiles of a test form its Q-matrix. The validity of cognitive diagnosis depends crucially on the correct specification of the Q-matrix. Typically, Q-matrices are determined by curricular experts. However, expert judgment is fallible. Data-driven estimation methods have been developed with the promise of greater accuracy in identifying the Q-matrix of a test. Yet, many of the extant methods encounter computational feasibility issues either in the form of excessive amounts of CPU times or inadmissible estimates. In this article, a two-step algorithm for estimating the Q-matrix is proposed that can be used with any cognitive diagnosis model. Simulations showed that the new method outperformed extant estimation algorithms and was computationally more efficient. It was also applied to Tatsuoka's famous fraction-subtraction data. The paper concludes with a discussion of theoretical and practical implications of the findings.