Tailoring metabolic activity assays for tumour-engineered 3D models

Monitoring cell behaviour in hydrogel-based 3D models is critical for assessing their growth and response to cytotoxic treatment. Resazurin-based PrestoBlue and AlamarBlue reagents are frequently used metabolic activity assays when determining cell responses. However, both assays are largely applied to cell monolayer cultures but yet to have a defined protocol for use in hydrogel-based 3D models. The assays' performance depends on the cell type, culture condition and measurement sensitivity. To better understand how both assays perform, we grew pancreatic cancer cells in gelatin methacryloyl and collagen hydrogels and evaluated their metabolic activity using different concentrations and incubation times of the PrestoBlue and AlamarBlue reagents. We tested reagent concentrations of 4 % and 10 % and incubation times of 45 min, 2 h and 4 h. In addition, we co-cultured cancer cells together with cancer-associated fibroblasts and peripheral blood mononuclear cells in gelatin methacryloyl hydrogels and subjected them to gemcitabine and nab-paclitaxel to evaluate how both assays perform when characterising cell responses upon drug treatment. CyQuant assays were conducted on the same samples and compared to data from the metabolic activity assays. In cancer monocultures, higher reagent concentration and incubation time increased fluorescent intensity. We found a reagent concentration of 10 % and an incubation time of 2 h suitable for all cell lines and both hydrogels. In multicellular 3D cultures, PrestoBlue and AlamarBlue assays detected similar cell responses upon drug treatment but overestimated cell growth. We recommend to assess cell viability and growth in conjunction with CyQuant assays that directly measure cell functions.