Differences in Outcomes Based on the Degree to Which Bone Defects Are Filled with Cancellous Allochip Bone Grafts in...

Enchondroma, the most common benign cartilage tumor in the hand, often presents as pain, swelling, or pathological fractures. While curettage is the standard treatment preventing fractures, the optimal way of managing the bone cavity remains debated. In this study, we investigated the impact of a filled bone defect on radiologic and clinical outcomes among patients with enchondroma.

We retrospectively reviewed patients with solitary enchondroma of the hand who underwent curettage followed by allogeneic cancellous bone chip impaction grafting. The patients were divided into two groups based on the extent to which their bone defects were filled post-curettage: Group 1 (complete filling) and Group 2 (incomplete filling, i.e., <50%). We reviewed demographic data, local recurrence data, complications, information on consolidation duration, data on range of motion (ROM), and functional scores.

This study included 59 patients (25 males and 34 females; mean age, 30.4 ± 11.9 years, with a range of 8-78). Group 1 contained 35 patients, and Group 2 contained 24. No nonunion occurred following curettage and grafting. The mean radiological consolidation period was 6.4 weeks (range: 5-18). There was no significant difference in consolidation time between Group 1 (6.8 weeks) and Group 2 (6.9 weeks) (p = 0.166). The ROM and functional scores also showed no significant differences between the groups, with musculoskeletal society scores of 98.8 for Group 1 and 99.8 for Group 2 (p = 0.63).

This study demonstrates that the use of the impaction technique combined with cancellous allochip bone grafting yields favorable results in the treatment of solitary hand enchondroma. The extent to which the bone defect was filled did not significantly impact the overall outcomes.