Renal cell carcinoma: survival and prognostic factors

Three hundred twenty-six patients treated at New York University from 1970 to 1982 were studied for survival in relationship to surgical stage, type of therapy, and pathologic characterization of the primary tumor. At the time of diagnosis 25.5 per cent of tumors were Stage I, 15 per cent Stage II, 28.5 per cent Stage III, and 31 per cent Stage IV. The retrospective study showed that patients with tumor confined within the capsule achieved the highest five- and ten-year survivals of 88 per cent and 66 per cent, respectively. Survivals decreased as tumor invaded perirenal fat (67% and 35%) or regional lymph nodes (17% and 5%). Tumor invasion into the renal vein alone did not significantly change five-year survival (84%) but lowered ten-year survival to 45 per cent. Patients with metastases at the time of nephrectomy did poorly regardless of site of metastases or kind of adjuvant therapy, except for those managed by surgical extirpation of the secondary lesion. Certain tumor characteristics were associated with a better prognosis, e.g., size below 5 cm in diameter, lack of invasion of collecting system, perirenal fat or regional lymph nodes, and predominance of clear or granular cells growing into a recognizable histologic pattern.