Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 5, 2025
Objectively Assessing Sports Concussion Utilizing Visual Evoked Potentials
Published on: April 27, 2021
Introduction of the 'Blue Card' Concussion Policy to Semi-Elite Australian Football: Medical Staff Experiences and
Jacob R Msando1, Gill Cowen2, Sarah A Harris3
1School of Health Sciences The University of Notre Dame Australia.
Insights
The Western Australian Football League's blue-card rule for concussion was found ineffective by medical staff, who do not support its continuation. They recommend improved concussion education from the Football Commission.
Area of Science:
- Sports Medicine
- Neurology
- Public Health
Background:
- The Western Australian Football League (WAFL) implemented an umpire-initiated "blue-card rule" to manage concussions.
- The effectiveness of this rule from a sports medicine perspective remained unassessed.
Purpose of the Study:
- To evaluate the experiences and perceptions of medical staff regarding the WAFL "blue-card rule" during the 2022-2023 seasons.
- To understand the impact of the rule on concussion management and medical staff confidence.
Main Methods:
- A cross-sectional study utilizing an online survey distributed to WAFL medical staff (doctors, physiotherapists, head trainers).
- Survey questions covered demographics, concussion knowledge, exposure, and perceptions of the "blue-card rule".
- Descriptive statistics and chi-square tests were used for data analysis (significance at p <0.05).
Main Results:
- A 48% response rate was achieved among medical staff.
- 70% of medical staff found the "blue-card rule" unhelpful and did not support its continuation.
- 67% believed umpires lacked the qualification to identify on-field concussions, and over two-thirds requested more pre-season concussion policy education.
Conclusions:
- WAFL medical staff perceived the "blue-card rule" as an ineffective concussion identification strategy.
- There is a strong recommendation for enhanced concussion policy education from the Football Commission prior to each season.
- Medical staff confidence in sideline assessment (33%) and diagnostic capabilities (17%) requires improvement.
Background:
The Western Australian Football League (WAFL) introduced a new umpire driven 'blue-card rule' for concussion, but its benefit to the sports medicine team is unknown.
Purpose:
To determine the experiences and perceptions of medical staff within the 2022-2023 Men's and Women's WAFL competitions following the introduction of the 'blue-card rule'.
Study Design:
Cross-sectional study.
Method:
An online survey was delivered through Qualtrics to all WAFL medical staff (doctors, physiotherapists, head trainers). The survey contained four sections (demographics, concussion knowledge, concussion exposure and blue-card perceptions) with closed and multiple-answer questions. Standard methods for reporting descriptive data were applied, including mean ± standard deviation (SD) and proportions (%). Between-group differences were assessed using chi-square tests, and significance was accepted at p <0.05.
Results:
Response rate was 48% (n=7 doctors, n=12 physiotherapists, n=12 head trainers). Most staff (70%) did not agree that the 'blue-card rule' was a helpful concussion policy or should remain within the WAFL. Staff also felt umpires are not qualified to identify suspected concussions on-field (67%). Over two-thirds of medical staff feel the Football Commission needs to provide education about concussion policies before the commencement of each season. Only 33% of medical staff felt completely confident in delivering a sideline assessment, and 17% felt completely confident in their diagnostic capabilities. Relationships between medical and other staff were not substantially impacted by the 'blue-card rule'.
Conclusions:
Medical staff within the WAFL reported the 'blue-card rule' as an ineffective concussion identification tool and did not support its continued use for future WAFL seasons. Staff suggested that the Football Commission needs to provide more education on concussion policies before the commencement of each season.
Level Of Evidence:
3.
