Developmental toxicity of alkylated PAHs and substituted phenanthrenes: Structural nuances drive diverse toxicity and...

Polycyclic aromatic hydrocarbons (PAHs) are a diverse class of chemicals that occur in complex mixtures including parent and substituted PAHs. To understand the hazard posed by complex environmental PAH mixtures, we must first understand the structural drivers of activity and mode of action of individual PAHs. Understanding the toxicity of alkylated PAHs is important as they often occur in higher abundance in environmental matrices and can be more biologically active than their parent compounds. 104 alkylated PAHs were screened from 11 different parent compounds with emphasis on substituted phenanthrenes and their structurally dependent toxicity differences. Using a high-throughput early life stage zebrafish assay, embryos were exposed to concentrations between 0.1 and 100 μM and assessed for morphological and behavioral outcomes. The aryl hydrocarbon receptor (AHR) is often implicated in the toxicity of PAHs and the induction of cytochrome P4501A (cyp1a) is an excellent biomarker of Ahr activation. Embryos were evaluated for cyp1a induction using a fluorescence reporter line. Alkyl and polar phenanthrene derivatives were further assessed for spatial cyp1a expression and Ahr dependence of morphological effects. In the alkyl PAH screen 35 (33.7%) elicited a morphological or behavioral response and of those 23 (65%) also induced cyp1a. 31 (29.8%) of the chemicals only induced cyp1a. Toxicity varied substantially in response to substitution location, the amount of ring substitutions and alkyl chain length. Cyp1a induction varied by parent compound group and was a poor indicator of morphological or behavioral outcomes. Polar phenanthrenes were more biologically active than alkylated phenanthrene derivatives and their toxicity was not dependent upon the Ahr2, Ahr1a or Ahr1b when tested individually, despite cyp1a induction by 50% of polar phenanthrenes. Our results demonstrated that induction of cyp1a did not always correlate with PAH toxicity or Ahr dependence and that the type and location of phenanthrene substitution determined potency.