Impact of Power and Time in Hepatic Microwave Ablation: Effect of Different Energy Delivery Schemes

Microwave ablation often involves the use of continuous energy-delivery protocols with a fixed power and time. To achieve larger ablation zones, a range of protocols and power levels have been studied in experimental studies. The objective of the present study was to develop and experimentally evaluate the performance of a coupled computational electromagnetic-bioheat transfer model of 2.45 GHz microwave ablation under a variety of continuous and pulsed power delivery schemes. The main aim was to obtain an in-depth knowledge of the influence of energy delivery settings on ablation zone profiles and thermal damage in the peri-ablation zone. In addition to the theoretical model, we evaluated the power delivery schemes using ex vivo experiments and compared them to previously published data from in vivo experiments. The results showed slight differences in terms of the ablation zone size for different power delivery schemes under ex vivo conditions, with the applied energy level being the most important factor that determines ablation zone size; however, under in vivo conditions, applying a high-power pulse prior to and following a longer constant power application (BOOKEND 95 W protocol) presented the most favorable ablation zones. Moreover, the modeling and experimental studies identified threshold applied power and ablation times beyond which increases did not yield substantive increases in ablation zone extents.