Atomic-scale structure of ZrO₂: Formation of metastable polymorphs

Metastable phases can exist within local minima in the potential energy landscape when they are kinetically "trapped" by various processing routes, such as thermal treatment, grain size reduction, chemical doping, interfacial stress, or irradiation. Despite the importance of metastable materials for many technological applications, little is known about the underlying structural mechanisms of the stabilization process and atomic-scale nature of the resulting defective metastable phase. Investigating ion-irradiated and nanocrystalline zirconia with neutron total scattering experiments, we show that metastable tetragonal ZrO₂ consists of an underlying structure of ferroelastic, orthorhombic nanoscale domains stabilized by a network of domain walls. The apparent long-range tetragonal structure that can be recovered to ambient conditions is only the configurational ensemble average of the underlying orthorhombic domains. This structural heterogeneity with a distinct short-range order is more broadly applicable to other nonequilibrium materials and provides insight into the synthesis and recovery of functional metastable phases with unique physical and chemical properties.