Comparative Analysis of Protist Communities in Oilsands Tailings Using Amplicon Sequencing and Metagenomics

The Canadian province of Alberta contains substantial oilsands reservoirs, consisting of bitumen, clay and sand. Extracting oil involves separating bitumen from inorganic particles using hot water and chemical diluents, resulting in liquid tailings waste with ecotoxicologically significant compounds. Ongoing efforts aim to reclaim tailings-affected areas, with protist colonisation serving as one assessment method of reclamation progress. Oilsands-associated protist communities have mainly been evaluated using amplicon sequencing of the 18S rRNA V4 region; however, this barcode may overlook important protist groups. This study examined how community assessment methods between the V4 and V9 regions differ in representing protist diversity across four oilsands-associated environments. The V9 barcode identified more operational taxonomical units (OTUs) for Discoba, Metamonada and Amoebozoa compared with the V4. A comparative shotgun metagenomics approach revealed few eukaryotic contigs but did recover a complete Paramicrosporidia mitochondrial genome, only the second publicly available from microsporidians. Both V4 and V9 markers were informative for assessing community diversity in oilsands-associated environments and are most effective when combined for a comprehensive taxonomic estimate, particularly in anoxic environments.