Diagnosis of hereditary ataxias: a real-world single center experience

This study aims to evaluate our experience in the diagnosis of hereditary ataxias (HAs), to analyze data from a real-world scenario.

This is a retrospective, cross-sectional, descriptive study conducted at a single Italian adult neurogenetic outpatient clinic, in 147 patients affected by ataxia with a suspicion of hereditary forms, recruited from November 1999 to February 2024. A stepwise approach for molecular diagnostics was applied: targeted gene panel (TP) next-generation sequencing (NGS) and/or clinical exome sequencing (CES) were performed in the case of inconclusive first-line genetic testing, such as short tandem repeat expansions (TREs) testing for most common spinocerebellar ataxias (SCA1-3, 6-8,12,17, DRPLA), other forms [Fragile X-associated tremor/ataxia syndrome (FXTAS), Friedreich ataxia (FRDA) and mitochondrial DNA-related ataxia, RFC1-related ataxia/CANVAS] or inconclusive phenotype-guided specific single gene sequencing.

A definitive diagnosis was reached in 36.7% of the cases. TREs testing was diagnostic in 30.4% of patients. The three most common TREs ataxias were FRDA (36.1%), SCA2 (27.8%), and RFC1-related ataxia/CANVAS (11.1%). In five patients, the molecular diagnosis was achieved by single gene sequencing and causative mutations were identified in POLG (2), SACS (1), DARS2 (1), MT-ATP6 (1). Of 94 patients with a suspicion of HAs of indeterminate genetic origin, 68 underwent new molecular evaluation using the NGS approach. In 28 of these cases, CES was performed after the TP sequencing resulted negative. In 13 patients, the diagnosis was achieved by NGS approach. In 7 of these 13 patients, the diagnosis was made by CES. Genes mutations identified as causative of HAs were found in SPG7 (4), SACS (1), CACNA1A (1), CACNA1G (1), EEF2 (1), PRKCG (1), KCNC3 (1), ADCK3 (1), SYNE1 (1), ITPR1 (1). A positive family history of ataxia and early onset of symptoms were associated with a higher likelihood of obtaining a definite diagnosis.

The molecular diagnosis of HAs remains a significant challenge for neurologists. Our data indicate that, in most cases, a diagnosis of HA can be established through first line genetic testing, particularly TREs testing. However, for patients with a clinical diagnosis of HA who do not achieve a molecular diagnosis through initial genetic tests, the use of NGS proves to be a valuable tool, providing a definitive diagnosis in approximately 20% of cases. Therefore, when feasible in clinical practice, integrating NGS testing, especially exome sequencing, into the diagnostic decision-making process for unsolved cases is crucial.