Maturation of striatal dopamine supports the development of habitual behavior through adolescence

Developmental trajectories during the transition from adolescence to adulthood contribute to the establishment of stable, adult forms of operation. Understanding the neural mechanisms underlying this transition is crucial for identifying variability in normal development and the onset of psychiatric disorders, which typically emerge during this time. Habitual behaviors can serve as a model for understanding brain mechanisms underlying the stabilization of adult behavior, while also conferring risk for psychopathologies. Dopaminergic (DA) processes in the basal ganglia are thought to facilitate the formation of habits; however, developmental trajectories of habits and the brain systems supporting them have not been characterized in vivo in developing humans. The current study examined trajectories of habitual behavior from adolescence to adulthood and sought to understand how the maturing striatal DA system may act as a potential mechanism in the process of habit formation. We used data from two longitudinal studies (combined n = 217, 10 - 32 years of age, 1-3 visits each, 320 total sessions) to characterize normative developmental trajectories of basal ganglia tissue iron concentration (a proxy for DA-related neurophysiology) and goal-direct and habitual control behaviors in a two-stage decision-making task. Tissue iron concentrations across the basal ganglia and habitual responding during the two-stage sequential decision-making task both increased with age (all p < 0.001). Importantly, habitual responding was associated with tissue iron concentrations in the putamen (F = 4.34, p = 0.014), such that increases in habitual responding were supported by increases in putamen tissue iron concentration during childhood through late adolescence. Exploratory analyses of further subdivisions of anatomical regions found that this association was specific to the posterior putamen. These results provide novel evidence in humans that habitual behavior continues to mature into adulthood and may be supported by increased specialization of reward systems.