The effect of calcium on acute sodium chloride toxicity in Daphnia species

Chloride concentrations in freshwater are rising, with toxic effects on aquatic life. In temperate regions with cold winters, road salt used for deicing paved surfaces is a primary cause. There is evidence that water hardness can modify salt toxicity, but data are insufficient to inform policy. Because calcium is a primary ion influencing water hardness and there is widespread calcium decline in lakes, we examined the effects of varying calcium concentrations on acute salt toxicity in three Daphnia species to gain a greater understanding of the water hardness-salt toxicity relationship. We conducted 48-hr acute sodium chloride (NaCl) toxicity tests, using chloride concentrations as our metric, on neonates less than 24 hrs old in six calcium treatments: 1.5 to 128 mg/L (hardness ∼7 to 323 mgCaCO3/L). We determined the effective concentration of chloride that was lethal to 10%, 25%, and 50% of the sample populations from each iso-female line in each calcium treatment. Acute NaCl toxicity decreased as calcium concentrations increased. The relationship between NaCl toxicity and calcium concentration differed among Daphnia, such that Daphnia catawba and Daphnia pulex were more sensitive to NaCl in lower calcium treatments and less sensitive in higher calcium treatments compared to Daphnia pulicaria. Our results provide evidence that water quality guidelines are not protective enough for aquatic life in very soft water (≤3 mg Ca2+/L, 11.3 mg CaCO3/L) because most ECxx values we found for Daphnia were significantly lower than Canada's national guidelines for short-term chloride exposure. There are already many lakes with calcium concentrations below 3 mg/L, and global widespread calcium decline may put more aquatic ecosystems at risk of experiencing NaCl toxicity.