Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 29, 2025
12:55
Chemical Gardens as Flow-through Reactors Simulating Natural Hydrothermal Systems
Published on: November 18, 2015
14.4K
Can Chemical Substances be Natural?
1Department of History and Philosophy of Science, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, UK.
Ambix
|February 6, 2025
Summary
The natural versus synthetic distinction in chemistry is complex. Naturalness is best understood as material origin, but applying it to chemical substances, not just samples, is a category mistake.
Area of Science:
- Chemistry
- Philosophy of Science
Background:
- The distinction between natural and synthetic substances is frequently used in chemistry.
- This distinction carries philosophical and practical weight in scientific discourse.
Purpose of the Study:
- To explore the philosophical and practical implications of the natural versus synthetic distinction in chemistry.
- To analyze different interpretations of 'natural' as applied to chemical substances.
Main Methods:
- Philosophical analysis of the term 'natural'.
- Examination of the application of 'natural' to chemical substances versus samples.
Main Results:
- Naturalness is best understood as a statement about the material origin of a substance.
- Applying 'natural' to a chemical substance as a general category, rather than specific samples, constitutes a category mistake.
- The utility of describing samples as 'natural' is limited and requires careful consideration.
Conclusions:
- The natural/synthetic dichotomy in chemistry requires careful philosophical and practical consideration.
- The term 'natural' should be applied cautiously, primarily to samples and with awareness of its limitations.
Related Concept Videos
02:17What is Organic Chemistry?
72.2K
Organic chemistry is the study of compounds of carbon called organic compounds. Organic compounds either originate from living organisms or are synthesized by chemists. A defining trait of these compounds is the presence of carbon as the principal element, which is bonded to other carbon atoms and other elements such as hydrogen, oxygen, nitrogen, and sulfur. The existence of a wide array of organic molecules is a consequence of carbon atoms’ ability to form up to four strong bonds to...
72.2K
01:25Aromatic Compounds: Overview
10.2K
In general, the term ‘aromatic’ indicates a pleasant smell or fragrance from fresh flowers, freshly prepared coffee, etc. In the early history of organic chemistry, many benzene derivatives were isolated from the pleasant odor oils of the plants. For example, vanillin was isolated from the oil of vanilla, methyl salicylate from the oil of wintergreen, and cinnamaldehyde from the oil of cinnamon. They all had a pleasant odor; hence the name aromatic was given.
In 1825, Faraday...
In 1825, Faraday...
10.2K
03:02Organic Compounds
51.0K
All living things are formed mostly of carbon compounds called organic compounds. The category of organic compounds includes both natural and synthetic compounds that contain carbon. Although a single, precise definition has yet to be identified by the chemistry community, most agree that a defining trait of organic molecules is the presence of carbon as the principal element, bonded to hydrogen and other carbon atoms. However, some carbon-containing compounds such as carbonates, cyanides, and...
51.0K
01:19Chemical Reactions
88.3K
A chemical reaction is a process by which the bonds in the atoms of substances are rearranged to generate new substances. Matter cannot be created or destroyed in a chemical reaction—the same type and number of atoms that make up the reactants are still present in the products. Merely, the rearrangement of chemical bonds produces new compounds.
Chemical Reactions Rearrange Atoms into New Substances
A chemical reaction takes starting materials—the reactants—and changes them...
Chemical Reactions Rearrange Atoms into New Substances
A chemical reaction takes starting materials—the reactants—and changes them...
88.3K
01:27Elements and Compounds
96.4K
Pure substances consist of only one type of matter. A pure substance can be an element or a compound. An element consists of only one type of atom, while a compound consists of two or more types of atoms held together by a chemical bond.
Elements
Elements are classified as atomic or molecular based on the nature of their basic units. They are unique forms of matter with specific chemical and physical properties that cannot break down into smaller substances by ordinary chemical reactions. There...
Elements
Elements are classified as atomic or molecular based on the nature of their basic units. They are unique forms of matter with specific chemical and physical properties that cannot break down into smaller substances by ordinary chemical reactions. There...
96.4K
02:58Chemistry of the Cell
41.6K
The cell is chemically composed of water, organic molecules and inorganic ions.
Water
The polarity of the water molecule and its resulting hydrogen bonding makes water a unique substance with special properties that are intimately tied to the processes of life. Life originally evolved in an aqueous environment, and most of an organism’s cellular chemistry and metabolism occur inside the aqueous contents of the cell’s cytoplasm. Special properties of water are its high heat capacity...
Water
The polarity of the water molecule and its resulting hydrogen bonding makes water a unique substance with special properties that are intimately tied to the processes of life. Life originally evolved in an aqueous environment, and most of an organism’s cellular chemistry and metabolism occur inside the aqueous contents of the cell’s cytoplasm. Special properties of water are its high heat capacity...
41.6K