Light environment and seasonal variation in the visual system of the red shiner (Cyprinella lutrensis)

The light environment underwater can vary dramatically over space and time, challenging the visual systems of aquatic organisms. To meet these challenges, many species shift their spectral sensitivities through changes in visual pigment chromophore composition and opsin expression. The red shiner (Cyprinella lutrensis) is a North American cyprinid minnow species that inhabits waters ranging widely in turbidity and temperature. We hypothesized that the visual system of the red shiner is plastic with chromophore composition and opsin expression varying in response to the environment. To test this hypothesis, we collected red shiners throughout the year from three Oklahoma creeks that vary in turbidity. We characterized the light environment by spectroradiometry, measured chromophore composition of the eyes with high performance liquid chromatography, characterized the mechanisms of chromophore metabolism, and examined ocular gene expression by RNA sequencing and de novo transcriptome assembly. We observed significantly higher proportions of the long wavelength-shifted A2 chromophore in the eyes of fish from the turbid site and in samples collected in winter, suggesting that there may be a temperature-dependent trade-off between chromophore-based spectral tuning and chromophore-related noise. Opsin expression varied between turbid and clear creeks, but did not align with light environment as expected, and the magnitude of these differences was limited compared with the differences in chromophore composition. We confirmed that red shiner CYP27C1 catalyzes the conversion of A1 to A2, but the ocular expression of CYP27C1 was not well correlated with A2 levels in the eye, suggesting conversion may be occurring outside the eye.