Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 27, 2025
A Unified Methodological Framework for Vestibular Schwannoma Research
Published on: June 20, 2017
Quality of Information Provided by Artificial Intelligence Chatbots Surrounding the Management of Vestibular
Daniele Borsetto1, Egidio Sia2, Patrick Axon1
1Department of Otolaryngology-Head & Neck Surgery, Cambridge University Hospitals NHS Trust, Cambridge, UK.
Objective:
To examine the quality of information provided by artificial intelligence platforms ChatGPT-4 and Claude 2 surrounding the management of vestibular schwannomas.
Study Design:
Cross-sectional.
Setting:
Skull base surgeons were involved from different centers and countries.
Intervention:
Thirty-six questions regarding vestibular schwannoma management were tested. Artificial intelligence responses were subsequently evaluated by 19 lateral skull base surgeons using the Quality Assessment of Medical Artificial Intelligence (QAMAI) questionnaire, assessing "Accuracy," "Clarity," "Relevance," "Completeness," "Sources," and "Usefulness."
Main Outcome Measure:
The scores of the answers from both chatbots were collected and analyzed using the Student t test. Analysis of responses grouped by stakeholders was performed with McNemar test. Stuart-Maxwell test was used to compare reading level among chatbots. Intraclass correlation coefficient was calculated.
Results:
ChatGPT-4 demonstrated significantly improved quality over Claude 2 in 14 of 36 (38.9%) questions, whereas higher-quality scores for Claude 2 were only observed in 2 (5.6%) answers. Chatbots exhibited variation across the dimensions of "Accuracy," "Clarity," "Completeness," "Relevance," and "Usefulness," with ChatGPT-4 demonstrating a statistically significant superior performance. However, no statistically significant difference was found in the assessment of "Sources." Additionally, ChatGPT-4 provided information at a significant lower reading grade level.
Conclusions:
Artificial intelligence platforms failed to consistently provide accurate information surrounding the management of vestibular schwannoma, although ChatGPT-4 achieved significantly higher scores in most analyzed parameters. These findings demonstrate the potential for significant misinformation for patients seeking information through these platforms.
