Related Experiment Video
Updated: May 27, 2025

Phage-Mediated Genetic Manipulation of the Lyme Disease Spirochete Borrelia burgdorferi
Published on: September 28, 2022
Should I stay or should I go: transmission trade-offs in phages and plasmids
Jana S Huisman1, Andrina Bernhard2, Claudia Igler3
1Physics of Living Systems, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, MA, USA.
Abstract:
Mobile genetic elements (MGEs), like temperate bacteriophages and conjugative plasmids, are major vectors of virulence and antibiotic resistance in bacterial populations. For reproductive success, MGEs must balance horizontal and vertical transmission. Yet, the cost of horizontal transmission (metabolic burden or host death) puts these transmission modes at odds. Using virulence-transmission trade-off (VTT) theory, we identify three groups of environmental variables affecting the balance between horizontal and vertical transmission: host density, host physiology, and competitors. We find that general theoretical predictions of the optimal response to environmental cues align with experimental evidence on the regulation of transmission by phages and plasmids. We further highlight gaps between theory and experiments, differences between phages and plasmids, and suggest areas for future research.
Insights
Mobile genetic elements balance horizontal and vertical transmission to spread virulence and antibiotic resistance. Environmental factors like host density influence this balance, aligning theory with experimental data.
Area of Science:
- Microbiology
- Evolutionary Biology
- Genetics
Background:
- Mobile genetic elements (MGEs), including bacteriophages and plasmids, are key drivers of bacterial virulence and antibiotic resistance.
- MGEs must balance horizontal and vertical transmission for successful propagation.
- The costs associated with horizontal transmission can conflict with MGE reproductive strategies.
Purpose of the Study:
- To investigate the influence of environmental variables on the balance between horizontal and vertical transmission of MGEs.
- To test predictions derived from virulence-transmission trade-off (VTT) theory.
- To identify differences and gaps between theoretical models and experimental findings for phages and plasmids.
Main Methods:
- Application of virulence-transmission trade-off (VTT) theory.
- Analysis of environmental factors: host density, host physiology, and competitors.
- Comparison of theoretical predictions with existing experimental evidence on MGE transmission regulation.
Main Results:
- Identified three key environmental variable groups influencing MGE transmission balance.
- Theoretical predictions regarding optimal responses to environmental cues generally align with experimental data.
- Observed alignment for both temperate phages and conjugative plasmids.
Conclusions:
- Environmental factors critically regulate the transmission strategies of MGEs.
- VTT theory provides a useful framework for understanding MGE evolution.
- Further research is needed to address discrepancies between theory and experiments and to explore phage-plasmid differences.
Related Concept Videos
Lysogenic Cycle of Bacteriophages
Lytic Cycle of Bacteriophages
Genomic DNA in Prokaryotes
Genomic Diversity in Bacteria
Although bacterial genomes are much...

