Ready, or not? A qualitative study of emergency medicine senior residents' perspectives on preparing for practice

The transition from residency to unsupervised practice challenges doctors to adapt to new environments and responsibilities. Past work has focused on how physicians acclimate to their new roles, raising questions about how residents might think proactively about transitions while still in training. This study explores senior emergency medicine (EM) residents' perspectives on preparedness for unsupervised practice and how they draw from training experiences to assess their evolving sense of preparedness.

The authors used a constructivist grounded theory approach, inviting all fourth-year EM residents from two residency programs to participate in semistructured interviews. Participants were asked to reflect on their preparedness for entering unsupervised practice and to imagine scenarios for which they felt unprepared. Two authors coded line by line using constant comparison, organizing data into codes and categories. The research team met to discuss relationships between codes, developing themes to theorize about the phenomenon of interest.

Sixteen residents were interviewed. The authors identified two overarching categories of themes. First, participants described individualized conceptualizations of preparedness, constructed from past workplace experiences and those they anticipated they would have in unsupervised practice. These conceptualizations emphasized drawing confidence from experience and developing adaptability to manage the uncertainties of medical practice. The second overarching category involved participants' efforts to gauge their own preparedness. To do so, they used interactions with others to assess their readiness to manage specific problems and made holistic appraisals across multiple experiences to assess their overall preparedness for unsupervised practice.

Trainees draw from past experiences to forecast their abilities to manage the inevitable uncertainties of unsupervised practice. These conceptualizations of preparedness reflect a capability approach to training, with informed confidence and dynamic self-appraisal. These findings suggest potential learning goals of senior trainees and considerations for medical educators to consider when fostering trainees' capabilities for unsupervised practice.