Tissue-Mimicking Materials for Breast Ultrasound Elastography Phantoms: A Systematic Review

Breast ultrasound elastography phantoms are valued for their ability to mimic human tissue, enabling calibration for quality assurance and testing of imaging systems. Phantoms may facilitate the development and evaluation of ultrasound techniques by accurately simulating the properties of breasts. However, selecting appropriate tissue-mimicking materials for realistic and accurate ultrasound exams is crucial to ensure the ultrasound system responds similarly to real breast tissue. We conducted a systematic review of the PubMed, Scopes, Embase, and Web of Sciences databases, identifying 928 articles in the initial search, of which 19 were selected for further evaluation based on our inclusion criteria. The chosen article focused on tissue-mimicking materials in breast ultrasound elastography phantom fabrication, providing detailed information on the fabrication process, the materials used, and ultrasound and elastography validation of phantoms. The phantoms fabricated from Polyvinyl Chloride Plastisol, silicon, and paraffin were best suited for mimicking breast, fatty, glandular, and parenchyma tissues. Adding scatterers to these materials facilitates accurate fatty and glandular breast tissue simulations, making them ideal for ultrasound quality assurance and elastography training. Future research should focus on developing more realistic phantoms for advanced medical training, improving the practice of difficult procedures, enhancing breast cancer detection research, and providing tailored tissue characteristics.