k-mer-based approaches to bridging pangenomics and population genetics

Many commonly studied species now have more than one chromosome-scale genome assembly, revealing a large amount of genetic diversity previously missed by approaches that map short reads to a single reference. However, many species still lack multiple reference genomes and correctly aligning references to build pangenomes can be challenging for many species, limiting our ability to study this missing genomic variation in population genetics. Here, we argue that k-mers are a very useful but underutilized tool for bridging the reference-focused paradigms of population genetics with the reference-free paradigms of pangenomics. We review current literature on the uses of k-mers for performing three core components of most population genetics analyses: identifying, measuring, and explaining patterns of genetic variation. We also demonstrate how different k-mer-based measures of genetic variation behave in population genetic simulations according to the choice of k, depth of sequencing coverage, and degree of data compression. Overall, we find that k-mer-based measures of genetic diversity scale consistently with pairwise nucleotide diversity (π) up to values of about π = 0.025 (R2 = 0.97) for neutrally evolving populations. For populations with even more variation, using shorter k-mers will maintain the scalability up to at least π = 0.1. Furthermore, in our simulated populations, k-mer dissimilarity values can be reliably approximated from counting bloom filters, highlighting a potential avenue to decreasing the memory burden of k-mer based genomic dissimilarity analyses. For future studies, there is a great opportunity to further develop methods to identifying selected loci using k-mers.