MS-RT: A Method for Evaluating MS/MS Clustering Performance for Metabolomics Data

The clustering of tandem mass spectra (MS/MS) is a crucial computational step to deduplicate repeated acquisitions in data-dependent experiments. This technique is essential in untargeted metabolomics, particularly with high-throughput mass spectrometers capable of generating hundreds of MS/MS spectra per second. Despite advancements in MS/MS clustering algorithms in proteomics, their performance in metabolomics has not been extensively evaluated due to the lack of database search tools with false discovery rate control for molecule identification. To bridge this gap, this study introduces the MS1-retention time (MS-RT) method to assess MS/MS clustering performance in metabolomics data sets. Here, we validate MS-RT by comparing MS-RT to established proteomics clustering evaluation approaches that utilize database search identifications. Additionally, we evaluate the performance of several MS/MS clustering tools on metabolomics data sets, highlighting their advantages and drawbacks. This MS-RT method and the MS/MS clustering tool benchmarking will provide valuable real world practical recommendations for tools and set the stage for future advancements in metabolomics MS/MS clustering.