Improving Simulation Model Accuracy for Friction Stir Welding of AA 2219

Modeling of friction stir welding (FSW) is challenging, as there are large gradients in both strain rate and temperature (typically between 450 and 500 °C in aluminum alloys) that must be accounted for in the constitutive law of the material being joined. Constitutive laws are most often calibrated using flow stresses from hot compression or hot torsion testing, where strain rates are much lower than those seen in the stir zone of the FSW process. As such, the current work employed a recently developed method to measure flow stresses at high strain rates and temperatures in AA 2219-T67, and these data were used in the development of a finite element (FE) simulation of FSW. Because heat generation during FSW is primarily a function of friction between the rapidly spinning tool and the plate, the choice of friction law and associated parameters were also studied with respect to FE model predictions. It was found that the Norton viscoplastic friction law provided the most accurate modeling results, for both the transient and steady-state phases of an FSW plunge experiment. It is likely that the superior performance of the Norton law was its ability to account for temperature and rate sensitivity of the plate material sheared by the tool, while the Tresca-limited Coulomb law favored contact pressure, with essentially no temperature or rate dependence of the local material properties. With optimized friction parameters and more accurate flow stresses for the weld zone, as measured by a high-pressure shear test, a 65% overall reduction in model error was achieved, compared to a model that employed a material law calibrated with hot compression or hot torsion test results. Model error was calculated as an equally weighted comparison of temperatures, torques, and forces with experimentally measured values.