Domestic violence in pregnancy: a systematic review of clinical guidelines

Domestic violence is a public health concern and human rights violation affecting more than one-third of all pregnant women globally. Abused pregnant women need several interventions to reduce domestic violence and its negative consequences on mother and child. The purpose of this study was to determine the quality, scope, and consistency of clinical guidelines for managing domestic violence during pregnancy.

This systematic review was based on the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses (PRISMA). Electronic databases of Scopus, PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, Up-to-date, Cochrane Library database, Google Scholar, and Guideline repositories, including NICE, SIGN, GAC, NHMRC, NGC, New Zealand Guidelines Group, TRIP, AHRQ, G-I-N, and MD Consult, using appropriate keywords were searched. Included studies were clinical guidelines containing recommendations about domestic violence in pregnancy and postpartum. Two reviewers used the AGREE II (Appraisal of Guidelines, Research, and Evaluation version 2) instrument to evaluate the quality of guidelines, and textual syntheses were used to appraise and compare the relevant recommendations. Out of 381 relevant published guidelines, 14 clinical guidelines were ultimately reviewed systematically.

Seven countries had a clinical guideline for domestic violence during pregnancy. None of the reviewed guidelines was rated > 75% across all domains of AGREE II while the highest-rated domains were scope, purpose, and clarity. Four related categories were recognized from the synthesis of recommendations within the appropriate guidelines. These consisted of an introduction, domestic violence in pregnancy, the role of health care professionals, and the resources. Recommendations for privacy and confidentiality, screening, identification, support, and documentation were the most commonly reported, which all of the guidelines advised them, suggesting the importance of identification of violence in pregnancy and support for abused pregnant women. 93% of the reviewed guidelines had recommendations on communication, support and building trust, child protection, and professional education and training.

The study findings suggest that there are currently gaps in clinical guidelines in various areas, including patterns of violence, the cycle of violence, identifying risk factors for violence during pregnancy, providing medical care, implementing home visitation programs, promoting self-care and empowerment, preventing violence, offering follow-up support, and conducting community education programs. Therefore, it is crucial to develop or adapt clinical guidelines for abused pregnant women, emphasizing their needs to ensure their safety and well-being.