Comparative effects of acetate and bicarbonate hemodialysis on left ventricular function

To assess the comparative effects of hemodialysis with acetate versus bicarbonate base on left ventricular systolic function, we performed M-mode echocardiography on 36 patients prior to and immediately following 4-hr maintenance hemodialysis. Patients were initially dialyzed against either sodium acetate or sodium bicarbonate and 1 week later were dialyzed against the alternate base. The mean velocity of circumferential fiber shortening (mean Vcf, circumferences/s) was used to assess left ventricular systolic function. In patients with normal pre-dialysis mean Vcf hemodialysis with acetate produced no significant change in mean Vcf, whereas hemodialysis with bicarbonate produced a significant increase in mean Vcf. In patients with low pre-dialysis mean Vcf hemodialysis with either base produced a significant increase in mean Vcf. Mean Vcf values obtained after hemodialysis with bicarbonate were significantly higher than those obtained after hemodialysis with acetate, both in patients with normal and low pre-hemodialysis mean Vcf. We conclude that hemodialysis with bicarbonate produces a comparatively greater improvement in left ventricular systolic function than hemodialysis with acetate.