Influence of imaging method on fat fraction estimation for assessing bone marrow in metastatic prostate cancer
Yassine N Azma1,2, Nada Boci3, Katarzyna Abramowicz3,4
1MRI Unit, The Royal Marsden NHS Foundation Trust, London, UK. Yassine.azma@rmh.nhs.uk.
Objective:
This study aimed to assess the accuracy of fat fraction estimation with clinically available Dixon sequences in normal-appearing marrow and bone metastases in the pelvis of metastatic prostate cancer patients.
Methods:
A prospective single-centre study was conducted with metastatic prostate cancer patients and healthy volunteers. Linearity and bias of fat fraction estimates from clinically available Dixon sequences were assessed against a 6-point PDw gradient echo (q-Dixon) sequence measuring the reference standard proton density fat fraction. Lesion fat fraction estimates were cross-compared using the Friedman test. Repeatability in volunteers was evaluated with Bland-Altman plots. Sensitivity of fat fraction estimates using TSE-Dixon sequences to specific absorption rate (SAR) related modifications were evaluated with correlation plots.
Results:
Thirty-three patients were recruited for this study. Significant (p < 0.05) absolute bias (12.4%) was demonstrated in the T1-weighted (T1w) Dixon measurements against the q-Dixon. Significant differences (p < 0.05) between fat fraction estimates provided by the T1w Dixon and PDw Dixon sequences were observed in 13 active and 6 treated lesions. Repeatability coefficients for fat fraction estimates ranged from 5.9 to 9.0% in the pelvic tissues of healthy volunteers. Reduction of slice number with repetition time for SAR had the greatest effect, reaching a maximum difference in fat fraction of 14.7% from the q-Dixon for the T2w-TSE Dixon in bone marrow.
Conclusions:
T1w Dixon methods can detect post-treatment changes but remain confounded by relaxation time biases. While all Dixon methods showed good repeatability, careful choice of SAR-related modifications is critical to maintaining accuracy for PD- and T2-weighted TSE sequences.
Key Points:
Question The clinical validity of signal-weighted fat fraction estimates versus proton density fat fraction for characterising metastatic bone lesions has not been fully assessed. Findings T1-weighted Dixon sequences in line with whole-body MRI international guidelines demonstrate significant fat fraction bias, particularly in lesions and muscle. Clinical relevance Fat fraction estimation using T1-weighted Dixon sequences recommended in international guidelines are highly sensitive to relaxation time biases, making underlying physiological changes potentially ambiguous.
