Barriers and Facilitators in Discussing Race and Racism with Youth: Overcoming Passivity and Building Confidence

This study examined youth-serving community mental health clinicians' multicultural counseling knowledge and awareness and their perceived barriers and facilitators in discussing race and racism with clients. Additionally, the study explored how clinicians' knowledge and awareness were related to their reports of barriers and facilitators in addressing race and racism.

The current study is a mixed-method study of 119 youth-serving community mental health clinicians across Washington State. We explore qualitative themes in clinicians' reports of perceived barriers and facilitators in broaching topics of race and racism. We also examine if reported barriers and facilitators correlate with the Multicultural Counseling Knowledge and Awareness Scale.

Qualitative themes emerged at the client-, clinician-, organizational-, and societal-levels. Barriers included clinicians not engaging in racism-related discussions unless clients initiated them, clinicians' discomfort or lack of confidence, and clinicians' perceptions of harm or limitations because of their racial identification. Clinicians were more willing to broach topics of race or racism with older clients, with stronger perceptions of rapport, and when topics were broached earlier in therapy. There was no statistically significant correlation between the count of perceived barriers or facilitators' and clinicians' multicultural counseling knowledge and awareness.

Qualitative and quantitative data highlight considerations for assessing and supporting clinicians' cultural humility. Enhancing multicultural competency and humility can help clinicians recognize their strengths and limitations, fostering a deeper understanding of clients' cultural backgrounds. Encouraging clinicians to facilitate open discussions about race and racism is a key step in this process.