Overcoming challenges in MSC-sEV therapeutics: insights and advances after a decade of research

Over the past decade, mesenchymal stromal cell-derived small extracellular vesicles (MSC-sEVs) have emerged as promising therapeutics, shifting the focus from MSC engraftment or differentiation to their secretion of sEVs-particularly those under 200 nm-that mediate regenerative and immunomodulatory functions. Transitioning from cell therapies to sEV-based therapies offers clinical advantages, including reduced challenges with cell viability, storage, and administration, and improved pharmacological predictability. However, manufacturing MSC-sEV products faces challenges in defining critical quality attributes (CQAs) for consistent identity and potency. Variability arises from differences in cell sources, culture conditions, enrichment techniques, and the inherent heterogeneity of MSCs. Even the use of immortalized clonal MSC lines may not fully eliminate variability, as factors such as developmental processes, epigenetic modifications, or genetic drift could lead to the re-emergence of heterogeneity. Establishing robust potency CQAs is further complicated by the complex, multimodal modes of action of MSC-sEV products, which involve diverse mechanisms impacting various cell types and processes. Traditional models of EV mediated signalling suggesting direct internalization of sEVs by target cells are increasingly challenged due to inefficient EV-uptake and the high therapeutic efficacy observed. Instead, the Extracellular Modulation of Cells by EVs (EMCEV) model proposes that MSC-sEVs exert their effects by modulating the extracellular environment, enabling a "one EV to many cells" interaction. In conclusion, while MSC-sEV products hold significant therapeutic promise due to their multimodal action and functional redundancy, manufacturing challenges and the complexity of defining potency CQAs remain hurdles to clinical translation. A pragmatic approach focusing on identifying key potency-related CQAs based on specific mechanisms of action-while recognizing that "the process defines the product"-may facilitate the advancement of MSC-sEV therapeutics into clinical applications.