The Cause-Effect Model of Master Sex Determination Gene Acquisition and the Evolution of Sex Chromosomes

The canonical model of vertebrate sex chromosome evolution predicts a one-way trend toward degradation. However, most sex chromosomes in lower vertebrates are homomorphic. Recent progress in studies of sex determination has resulted in the discovery of more than 30 master sex determination (MSD) genes, most of which are from teleost fish. An analysis of MSD gene acquisition, recombination suppression, and sex chromosome-specific sequences revealed correlations in the modes of MSD gene acquisition and the evolution of sex chromosomes. Sex chromosomes remain homomorphic with MSD genes acquired by simple mutations, gene duplications, allelic variations, or neofunctionalization; in contrast, they become heteromorphic with MSD genes acquired by chromosomal inversion, fusion, and fission. There is no recombination suppression with sex chromosomes carrying MSD genes gained through simple mutations. In contrast, there is extensive recombination suppression with sex chromosomes carrying MSD genes gained through chromosome inversion. There is limited recombination suppression with sex chromosomes carrying MSD genes gained through transposition or translocation. We propose a cause-effect model that predicts sex chromosome evolution as a consequence of the acquisition modes of MSD genes, which explains the evolution of sex chromosomes in various vertebrates. A key factor determining the trend of sex chromosome evolution is whether non-homologous regions are created during the acquisition of MSD genes. Chromosome inversion creates inversely homologous but directly non-homologous sequences, which lead to recombination suppression but retain recombination potential. Over time, recurrent recombination in the inverted regions leads to the formation of strata and may cause the degradation of sex chromosomes. Depending on the nature of deletions in the inverted regions, sex chromosomes may evolve with dosage compensation, or the selective retention of haplo-insufficient genes may be used as an alternative strategy.