Related Experiment Video
Updated: Jun 14, 2025

Evaluation of an Exclusive Spur Dike U-Turn Design with Radar-Collected Data and Simulation
Published on: February 1, 2020
Modeling dilemma zone at urban signalized intersections using crowdsourced trajectory data.
Pramesh Pudasaini1, Henrick Haule2, Yao-Jan Wu1
1Department of Civil and Architectural Engineering and Mechanics, The University of Arizona, 1209 E 2nd St, Tucson, AZ 85721, United States.
Drivers face a dilemma zone at yellow lights, increasing crash risks. This study accurately quantifies this zone using crowdsourced data, improving intersection safety strategies.
Area of Science:
- Traffic Safety Engineering
- Driver Behavior Analysis
- Transportation Systems
Background:
- The stop/go dilemma at yellow traffic signals poses significant risks for rear-end and red-light running collisions.
- Existing methods for defining the dilemma zone, particularly Type II, have limitations, while Type I requires high-quality trajectory data often difficult to obtain.
- Accurate modeling and evaluation of the Type I dilemma zone dynamics represent a critical research gap.
Purpose of the Study:
- To accurately quantify the Type I dilemma zone using a large dataset of crowdsourced vehicle trajectory data.
- To address limitations in existing dilemma zone modeling and evaluation methods.
- To analyze driver behavior within the dilemma zone to assess collision risks and inform safety strategies.
Main Methods:
- Utilized a large sample of crowdsourced vehicle trajectory data for dilemma zone quantification.
- Implemented quantile regression to integrate driver-vehicle attributes into stopping and clearing distance calculations.
- Analyzed driver behavior in the approach area to identify potential collision risks.
Main Results:
- The Type I dilemma zone is consistently formed at very high vehicle approach speeds across 15 intersection approaches.
- The proposed method achieved low root mean squared errors of 14.8 ft and 25.1 ft for zone boundary estimation.
- Demonstrated the superiority of the proposed method over existing dilemma zone quantification techniques.
Conclusions:
- Crowdsourced data and quantile regression provide an accurate method for quantifying the Type I dilemma zone.
- Understanding dilemma zone dynamics is crucial for developing effective intersection safety and signal timing strategies.
- This research offers an empirical foundation for enhancing traffic safety and reducing intersection crashes.
Related Concept Videos
Design Example: Alignment of a Road Line Using GIS
Social Traps
Schemas
Design Example: Measuring Distance Between Two Points with Obstructions
Design Example: Analyzing Capacity Contours for Flood Risk Assessment
Design Example: Setting a Curve Using Design Data

