Comparative analysis of semantic-segmentation models for screen film mammograms

Accurate segmentation of mammographic mass is very important as shape characteristics of these masses play a significant role for radiologist to diagnose benign and malignant cases. Recently, various deep learning segmentation algorithms have become popular for segmentation tasks. In the present work, rigorous performance analysis of ten semantic-segmentation models has been performed with 518 images taken from DDSM dataset (digital database for screening mammography) with 208 mass images ϵ BIRAD3, 150 mass images ϵ BIRAD4 and 160 mass images ϵ BIRAD5 classes, respectively. These models are (1) simple convolution series models namely- VGG16/VGG19, (2) simple convolution DAG (directed acyclic graph) models namely- U-Net (3) dilated convolution DAG models namely ResNet18/ResNet50/ShuffleNet/XceptionNet/InceptionV2/MobileNetV2 and (4) hybrid model, i.e. hybrid U-Net. On the basis of exhaustive experimentation, it was observed that dilated convolution DAG models namely- ResNet50, ShuffleNet and MobileNetV2 outperform other network models yielding cumulative JI and F1 score values of 0.87 and 0.92, 0.85 and 91, 0.84 and 0.90, respectively. The segmented images obtained by best performing models were subjectively analyzed by participating radiologist in terms of (a) size (b) margins and (c) shape characteristics. From objective and subjective analysis it was concluded that ResNet50 is the optimal model for segmentation of difficult to delineate breast masses with dense background and masses where both masses and micro-calcifications are simultaneously present. The result of the study indicates that ResNet50 model can be used in routine clinical environment for segmentation of mammographic masses.